Jump to content

The Survival Of The Republic Depends On Our Citizenry, Not Our Courts


Recommended Posts

The Federalist

History teaches us that the true guardians of democracy are not state supreme courts or rouge lawmakers, but the people themselves.

Joshua Claybourn
January 08, 2024

In a landscape where the law and politics intertwine, Colorado and Maine’s decision to bar former President Donald Trump from their primary ballots resonates deeply within the heart of American democracy. This isn’t a mere legal maneuver; it’s a high-stakes dance on the tightrope of American electoral politics, balancing constitutional law and political strategy.

At the heart of these decisions lies the rarely invoked insurrection clause of the 14th Amendment, a relic from the Civil War that now gains newfound significance. Essentially, it prohibits individuals who have actively worked against the Constitution through insurrection from holding any government position.

Ultimately, this issue forces us to ponder how, as a nation, we determine who ascends to the highest echelons of leadership and who does not. It’s a question that doesn’t merely seek an answer; it demands profound introspection and contemplation about the very essence of our self-government.

Much of this boils down to one crucial point: Republican voters and influencers refrained from decisively repudiating Trump after the turbulent events of Jan. 6. As a result, certain Republicans, and an even larger number of Democrats, have resorted to legal measures as a final recourse to address what they see as a failure by the electorate to uphold democratic norms.

History helps us grasp our current situation, back to a time when another great republic grappled with the looming threat of tyranny. The Roman Republic’s struggle, particularly during the era of Lucius Cornelius Sulla, offers a valuable parallel.


The Collective Will of the Citizenry

Today, as we confront our own challenges, the lessons from Rome reverberate with striking relevance. American self-government cannot be single-handedly safeguarded by individuals like Robert Mueller or Jack Smith or Maine’s secretary of state, or even institutions like the Supreme Court. Our republic, much like Rome, depends on the collective will and actions of our citizenry.

When confronting any politician who challenges democratic values or entertains authoritarian rhetoric, it is crucial to recognize that our salvation cannot hinge solely on court rulings. If there is no corresponding political will to uphold them, such rulings hold no more value than the paper they are written on. The duty to safeguard the integrity and principles of our republic lies within us — the citizens — particularly with voters. There exists no savior apart from our own collective effort to vote and to persuade our fellow countrymen.

Moreover, the underlying strategy is destined for failure. Even if the Supreme Court were to uphold Colorado and Maine’s decisions, the outcome would simply be that states would make the call. Trump wouldn’t be removed from all 50 states, and it’s highly improbable that swing states would take such action. So what’s the purpose?


We’re at a critical juncture where reliance on legal tactics to combat perceived threats to democracy might actually weaken it. Barring Trump might satisfy a momentary urge for retribution, but it does nothing to address the deeper issues eroding our democratic foundations. It’s a Band-Aid on a bullet wound.

We, the people, are the bedrock of our republic. Our power lies in the ballot box and the marketplace of ideas, not in legal gambits. The path to preserving our democratic ideals isn’t through exclusion but through engagement, education, and the relentless pursuit of truth. In the end, our democracy’s fate lies not in courtrooms or legislatures, but in our hands. It’s time we remember that before it’s too late. Our republic’s future depends not on silencing voices but on strengthening our own.


  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • 1713768588
  • Create New...